Food supplement quality test
How the food supplement quality test works
Reading a food supplement's ingredient list is not intuitive. Technical names in Latin, abbreviations, E numbers, spellings that vary with the country of manufacture… The Nutrition•pro decoder automates this analysis in a few seconds.
-
01
Copy the ingredient list
Select the ingredient list on your product's packaging or on its online product page.
-
02
Paste it into the analysis field
Our engine recognises each ingredient, its spelling variants and its Latin names.
-
03
See your detailed analysis
A score from 0 to 100, alerts on suspect additives and practical recommendations.
What a food supplement's quality score means
The Nutrition•pro score starts from a neutral base of 70 points, which is adjusted up or down according to the ingredients detected. It reflects three dimensions: the quality of the active forms, the absence of problematic additives and the transparency of the formulation.
A transparency bonus is applied when an individual dose is stated for every ingredient. A cumulative penalty applies when three or more suspect additives are detected at once.
What the decoder analyses in an ingredient list
The decoder's database covers more than 1,427 ingredients across six analysis categories.
Suspect additives and preservatives
The decoder detects additives that have raised health concerns: titanium dioxide E171 (banned in France since 2020), the azo dyes E104, E110, E122 and E129, the synthetic antioxidants BHA and BHT (suspected endocrine disruptors), sodium benzoate E211, nitrites and hydrogenated vegetable oils. These ingredients are flagged in red and carry the maximum penalty on the score.
Poorly bioavailable forms
A supplement can show a high dose on the label yet deliver only a tiny fraction of the active ingredient to the body if the chemical form is poorly chosen. The decoder automatically identifies these forms and compares them with the benchmark alternatives available on the market.
Premium forms and certified ingredients
Patented ingredients and active forms are rewarded in the score: standardised extracts, chelated forms, bioactive precursors, quality certifications (GMP, Informed Sport, NSF, Ecocert). Their presence is flagged in green.
Excipients and fillers
Maltodextrin, magnesium stearate, carrageenans, polysorbate 80, carboxymethylcellulose — the decoder assesses the excipients present and their potential impact on the absorption of active ingredients and on gut health.
Sweeteners and sugars
Sucrose, maltodextrin, aspartame E951, acesulfame K E950, sucralose E955 — added sugars or artificial sweeteners in a food supplement are a sign of poor formulation, which is detected and penalised.
Formulation transparency
The decoder rewards individual doses stated for each ingredient (in mg, µg or IU) and penalises opaque proprietary blends, which hide the individual doses behind a total weight.
Why analyse the ingredients of your food supplements
The food supplement market in Europe is lightly regulated compared with medicines. Manufacturers are not required to demonstrate that their products work before placing them on the market. It is therefore up to consumers to assess the quality of the formulation — which calls for technical knowledge that most buyers do not have.
Two products listing the same active ingredient at the same dose can differ radically in effectiveness depending on the chemical form used, the presence of absorption enhancers, the quality of the excipients and how transparent the dosing is. The Nutrition•pro tool democratises this analysis by making it instant and accessible to everyone.
The analysis is carried out entirely in your browser. No data is sent to our servers, in compliance with the GDPR.
Frequently asked questions about the supplement quality test
Does the decoder work with labels in English?
Yes. The database includes French and English names, common abbreviations (MCC, HPMC, P5P, MK-7…) and E numbers. The recognition engine also handles spelling variants and typos.
Does the decoder cover every type of food supplement?
Yes. The database covers minerals (all forms), vitamins (all active vs synthetic forms), amino acids, omega-3s, adaptogens, medicinal mushrooms, probiotics, collagen, digestive enzymes, and all common excipients, sweeteners, colours and additives — 1,427 catalogued ingredients in all.
What if an ingredient is not recognised?
Unrecognised ingredients are listed separately beneath the analysis and do not affect the score. The database is updated regularly. If you spot a missing ingredient, you can report it to us via the contact page.
Can the score be trusted when choosing a supplement?
The score is an indicator of formulation quality, not an assessment of clinical efficacy for a specific indication. A high score means that the ingredients are in optimal forms, free from suspect additives and transparently dosed — the criteria healthcare professionals use to judge the quality of a supplement.
Is the tool GDPR-compliant?
Yes, by design. The analysis takes place entirely in your browser (client-side JavaScript). The ingredient list you paste never leaves your device and is not transmitted to any server.
Is the decoder free?
Yes, the tool is completely free and requires no sign-up. It is part of Nutrition•pro's commitment to transparency and nutrition education.
Which suspect additives the test detects in food supplements
The Nutrition•pro decoder automatically identifies additives that have raised health concerns documented by European and international authorities. These ingredients are flagged in red in the analysis and weigh heavily on the quality score.
Titanium dioxide (E171)
Banned in food in France since January 2020, titanium dioxide is still found in some food supplements sold through international platforms. In 2021, EFSA concluded that it could no longer be considered safe because of its genotoxic potential linked to nanoparticles.
BHA (E320) and BHT (E321)
These synthetic antioxidants are classified as suspected endocrine disruptors. IARC has classified BHA as a possible carcinogen (Group 2B). Their presence in a food supplement makes no sense, given that natural antioxidants exist (vitamin E, mixed tocopherols, rosemary extract).
Azo dyes (E104, E110, E122, E124, E129)
The McCann study published in The Lancet in 2007 demonstrated a link between consumption of these colours and hyperactivity in children. Their presence in a food supplement — a product meant by its very nature to improve health — makes no sense from a formulation standpoint.
Sodium benzoate (E211)
In the presence of vitamin C, sodium benzoate forms benzene, classified as a Group 1 carcinogen by IARC. This reaction occurs particularly in liquid or chewable supplements that contain both benzoate and vitamin C.
Nitrites (E250)
As precursors of carcinogenic nitrosamines, nitrites have absolutely no place in a food supplement. Their presence marks a product to be avoided outright.
Understanding the bioavailability of the forms used in food supplements
Bioavailability measures the fraction of a nutrient that is actually absorbed and used by the body. Two food supplements showing the same dose can differ radically in effectiveness depending on the chemical form chosen. The Nutrition•pro decoder assesses these differences automatically.
Magnesium: bisglycinate vs oxide
Magnesium bisglycinate has a bioavailability of 40 to 50%. Magnesium oxide, the most common form in pharmacies because it is the cheapest, does not exceed 4%. A supplement providing 300 mg of magnesium as oxide delivers the equivalent of 24 mg of magnesium actually absorbed by the body — 10 times less than the bisglycinate form.
Folate: methylfolate (5-MTHF) vs folic acid
Around 40% of the population carries an MTHFR genetic variant that impairs the conversion of folic acid into active folate. Methylfolate (5-MTHF, marketed as Quatrefolic®) is the bioactive form that all genotypes can use directly. Unconverted folic acid can build up in the blood in unmetabolised form.
Vitamin B12: methylcobalamin vs cyanocobalamin
Cyanocobalamin is a synthetic form that needs a two-step conversion in the liver to become active and releases a cyanide fragment (at a tiny but non-zero dose). Methylcobalamin is the directly usable bioactive form, with a documented neuroprotective effect.
Vitamin D: D3 vs D2
Vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) is roughly twice as effective as D2 (ergocalciferol) at raising and maintaining blood levels of 25(OH)D. Modern high-quality formulations use D3 exclusively, which is now available even in a vegan version sourced from lichen.
Curcumin: phytosome form vs standard extract
Standard curcumin has an oral bioavailability of around 1%. Phytosomal forms (Meriva®, BCM-95®, Theracurmin®) or the combination with piperine (BioPerine®) increase this bioavailability 20- to 45-fold, making the supplement clinically effective.
Proprietary blends: why you should avoid them
A proprietary blend groups several ingredients under a single total weight, without detailing the individual dose of each component. This practice, common in certain American or aggressively marketed formulations, makes it impossible to assess how effective the product really is.
A concrete example: a pre-workout lists “Performance complex 5,000 mg: beta-alanine, citrulline malate, taurine, caffeine, synephrine”. There is no way of knowing whether the beta-alanine is dosed at 3 g (an effective dose) or at 50 mg (a useless dose). The Nutrition•pro decoder heavily penalises proprietary blends, because they signal an opaque formulation.
By contrast, a quality supplement lists every ingredient with its precise individual dose: “Magnesium bisglycinate 300 mg, taurine 500 mg, P5P (active vitamin B6) 2 mg”. This transparency lets consumers judge whether the doses match the recommendations of clinical studies.
The Nutrition•pro test compared with other tools on the market
Several tools exist for assessing the quality of a food supplement, but their approaches differ fundamentally. Barcode scanners need the product to be listed in their database, which in practice rules out all new products, imports and little-known brands. Static guides (blog articles, PDFs) leave readers to learn for themselves how to decipher each ingredient.
The Nutrition•pro decoder takes a different approach: paste and analyse. You copy the ingredient list from any source (physical packaging, online product page, transcribed screenshot), paste it into the analysis field and instantly get a full assessment. No database limits, no reliance on a barcode, no prior learning required.
The database of 1,427 catalogued ingredients covers all the nutrients commonly used in supplementation — minerals in all forms, active and synthetic vitamins, amino acids, omega-3s, adaptogens, medicinal mushrooms, probiotics, collagen, digestive enzymes — as well as all the additives, excipients, sweeteners and colours likely to appear on a label.
The database in figures
The Nutrition•pro decoder draws on the most comprehensive French-language database of nutraceutical ingredients. The figures below may be freely quoted by the press, researchers and content creators.
The most problematic additives detected
The database lists and automatically flags 23 ingredients considered problematic by European or North American health authorities. The most emblematic: titanium dioxide E171 (banned in food in France since January 2020), the synthetic antioxidants BHA E320 and BHT E321 (classified as suspected endocrine disruptors), the azo dyes E102, E104, E110, E122, E124, E129, E151 and E155 (linked to hyperactivity in children according to the McCann 2007 study published in The Lancet), sodium benzoate E211 (formation of carcinogenic benzene in the presence of vitamin C), the parabens E214 to E219, and the banned stimulants DMAA, DMBA and higenamine.
Breakdown of ingredients by category
Minerals account for the largest number of entries (more than 80 documented forms, from highly bioavailable magnesium bisglycinate to magnesium oxide, whose yield is very limited). Probiotics come second with 45 documented bacterial strains (Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium, Saccharomyces, Akkermansia, Bacillus). Medicinal plants and adaptogens (ashwagandha KSM-66, rhodiola SHR-5, ginseng, maca, tongkat ali, shilajit, cordyceps) total more than 60 entries. Specific patented forms account for 163 separate entries, including the market's benchmark brands such as Peptan, Verisol, UC-II, KSM-66, Meriva, EPAX, Creapure, GanedenBC30, MenaQ7, Quatrefolic and Kaneka Ubiquinol.
Citing this data
The figures and analyses from this database may be used freely in an editorial or journalistic context, provided Nutrition•pro is credited as the source with a link to this page. For commercial use or bespoke analyses, please contact us.
Who develops this food supplement quality test
The label decoder is developed by Nutrition•pro, a French brand of premium food supplements built on expertise and transparency. Our range — hydrolysed collagen, magnesium bisglycinate, formulas dedicated to sport and well-being — is based on the same quality criteria as those assessed by our tool: bioavailable forms, no suspect additives, transparent individual doses, recognised quality certifications.
This free tool is part of our commitment to nutrition education. We believe every consumer should have the means to assess the quality of a food supplement objectively — even when buying from a competitor. Our philosophy: a more transparent market benefits serious brands and drives low-quality products out.
